Save City Creek
Campaign


Mission Accomplished!
Click Here For Info

Development &
Environmental
Codes / Laws


Stay Connected
Signup For FFRD's
Email Listserv

Click to Signup
 

City Creek Development - Points of Concern

     
 
It is responsible development when existing neighborhoods are not damaged, the developer has the opportunity to make a profit, and Pocatello has homes to attract neighbors who will contribute as much as they receive.
 
 

* Situation: Preliminary approval has been given for over 66 houses to be built on what was only 11 lots, adjacent to City Creek, and on a dead-end extension of South Lincoln.

 
 
* Neighborhoods were not informed of the plan by the developer, or by notice to allow participation in the planning and review process.
  • Law suits, hurt feelings, emotional issues: City Planning and CDC processes and priorities placed Old Town's and City Creek's quality of life and major family asset value, their home, below developer profits.
  • This is like the governor's decision for a coal fired generator to be located at the old FMC plant. In both cases there was no input from impacted parties. Both decisions will benefit one group and impose the costs and hardships on a much larger group.

    * The Community Development Commission decision to approve "City Creek Subdivision" development failed to consider key legal and technical factors:
  • The City's 2003 Comprehensive Plan does not have zoning ordinances implementing the plan, as required by Idaho Code § 67-6511 & 6524, and Pocatello Ordinance 16.28.020.
  • The proposed "City Creek Subdivision" was reviewed based on a zoning map open space factor (OSF) of 2.3, when the ordinance worksheet required an OSF of 15.
  • FFRD's legal counsel stated that the "City Creek Subdivision" cannot be approved until adoption of ordinances implementing the 2003 comprehensive plan.
 
 
  • Violates ordinance under which staff requires: traffic impact studies, approval of SE Idaho Dept. of Health, and a statement of how carries out Comprehensive Plan.
 
 

* Perception Factors. Neighborhood and city residents, City Creek recreational users, professional planners and economists have identified off site negative impacts including:

  • Traffic issues: Access road design factors such as width, grade, curbing; vehicle volume, speed, noise; neighborhood children and elderly safety; delivery access.
  • Safety issues: Grass fire safety, police-fire-ambulance access; only one way in-out of the proposed development.
  • Property value issues: Loss of "walkable-livable neighborhood" quality of life; traffic impact exacerbated by possible changes to adjoining streets (Lincoln, Whitman, & Johnson) parking, street width, one-way designation, etc.
  • Storm water issues: runoff erosion and flooding similar to east bench situations
  • City Creek recreation ecosystem issues: Quality of recreation loss: concerns ranging from lost habitat for birds and wildflowers to noise and privacy.
  • Water-sewer impact: City aquifer and sewer capacity and costs to expand.
  • Costs: No cost/benefit analysis for the city. Widening streets, replace bridges, future bench expansion costs, wells, lower values-less taxes. On the average, for every $1 from subdivision development, there is a $1.15 in cost.
  • No housing need: Pocatello has lost population; over 20% of our market is from speculative investment, the first market to die when interest rates change.
 
     
© Families For Responsible Development - All Rights Reserved